Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Walyullah's avatar

Question (new here), how does one integrate BDS boycott campaigns with shariah compliant ETF funds? Cuz those are completely managed for you right? Is there any way to remove or "blacklist" certain companies from your managed account?

Or is the only way to integrate boycott campaigns to manage your own portfolio all by yourself?

Expand full comment
Driss's avatar

Great update, Safeer! I really appreciate the transparency and the structured approach you're bringing to the community. 🙌

Your mix of 75% QQQ-based investing with 25% active selection is an interesting balance—offering broad exposure to tech leaders while still allowing for targeted opportunities. I can definitely see the benefits, especially for those looking to automate their investing.

That said, one challenge I often see with index-heavy strategies, even with Shariah filters, is that they don’t always go deep enough on compliance. Some companies pass initial screens but still have high debt reliance or generate revenue from non-halal sources.

Beyond compliance, indices like QQQ tend to overweight past winners, meaning investors often pay a premium for momentum stocks while potentially overlooking undervalued, high-quality businesses.

That’s why my approach leans fully active, focusing on:

- Business model strength & sustainability

- Debt structure & reliance on interest-based income

- Revenue composition & halal earnings quality

- Valuation to avoid overpaying for growth

I completely get why a hybrid approach works for many investors—especially for simplicity—but for my profile, I prefer full control over stock selection to optimize both Shariah compliance & long-term value creation.

Curious—how do you personally refine your stock exclusions beyond standard debt filters? Would love to hear your thought process!

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts